Search
Close this search box.

Niceville baseball falls to South Walton 3-0 in pitchers’ duel

The Eagles ran into one of the nation's top arms Tuesday night, as South Walton's Coleman Borthwick led the Seahawks to a shutout.

After reeling off four straight wins, Niceville’s momentum met its match Tuesday night at the Hill.

  • No. 22-ranked South Walton rode a dominant outing from Coleman Borthwick — a projected top-10 MLB draft pick and Auburn commit — to blank the Eagles 3-0 in a game that played out as a pitchers’ duel from the first pitch.

Niceville sophomore Ethan Thomas matched Borthwick nearly pitch for pitch, but the Seahawks scratched across just enough runs to make it hold up.

South Walton struck first in the opening inning when Nathan Whitney singled and came around to score on a hit from Vaughn Howard, giving the Seahawks a 1-0 lead.

The score stayed there until the third, when Borthwick singled, Whitney doubled and Howard singled to push the lead to 3-0. Howard was thrown out trying to stretch his hit into a double, but not before Borthwick and Whitney had crossed the plate.

  • “Big-time at-bats. He was ready to swing the bat,” South Walton Head Coach Nick Borthwick said of Howard. “Vaughn works as hard as any player I ever had.”

From there, Thomas and the Niceville defense kept the Eagles within striking distance. Colton Cook ripped a double in the fourth, and the Eagles threatened again in the sixth when Jake Buis singled and Remington Crum drew a walk. But South Walton’s pitching held firm to preserve the shutout.

“Anytime you play Niceville at the Hill, you better be ready for a dogfight,” Coach Borthwick said. “I’m proud of my guys. I’m really proud of how they fought. We pitched very well, and I liked our defense and I liked our intensity. I love the fact that this team embraces the fight. Niceville’s a great team, much respect to Coach Bruce and his staff.”

South Walton (17-4) travels to Bozeman on Friday.
Niceville (14-6) heads to Arnold on Thursday.

PROMOTION

Join the conversation...

Continue reading 👇

Community Comments

“Not one mention of the Niceville Swim Team state champion winners in both bits and girls events, as well as their college signings?”
Respond
“TREXX WOE Facebook never delete You are EXPOSED!!!! POSTING IT NOW AGAIN!!!! SCREEN SHOT”
Respond
“Destin is ruined. Worked my whole adult life there left before it went dark.👋😎 Y'all can have it.”
Respond
“Y'all can have destin. It's too dark for me”
Respond
“So thankful for smart policeman that knew about the pond/child draw to water of the autistic. If not for his knowledge this child would have been out in the mosquitos...”
Respond
“Have porch monkeys taken over, I have lived in pcola my whole and they fack everything up. We have chicken bone beach to deal with. Oh I'm 67 and born...”
Respond
Ken commented on WordroW: June 4, 2026
“1:05, 4 attempts”
Respond
“I forgot to mention, I may even cross the new bridge into downtown and have a beer at one of the local bars, after all, the last time I crossed...”
Respond
“I'm going to be fair and say, I'm pretty impressed by the progress of the new bridge. After all, it's a heavily used highway and space is very limited, businesses...”
Respond

GET OUR FREE LOCAL NEWSLETTER

Get the weekday email that actually makes reading local news enjoyable again.