Niceville girls soccer’s historic season ends in heartbreak against St. Thomas Aquinas

The Lady Eagles fall 1-0 in DeLand as St. Thomas Aquinas claims a state-record 16th girls' soccer title.
Photo courtesy of Kelly Fernandez

On paper, everything pointed to Niceville’s favor. But as we know, unfortunately, games aren’t played on paper.

  • After what was unquestionably their best shot at winning a first state title in program history, Niceville will have to wait a little longer, as the Lady Eagles fell to St. Thomas Aquinas 1-0 in the Class 6A state championship Wednesday at Spec Martin Stadium.

The Lady Raiders’ defense was elite and goalkeeper Aimee Colson was on fire. At the 20-minute mark, Belen Cassina fired a goal that sailed past Eden Shaw and into the back of the net for what proved to be the game’s only score — and the first goal Niceville had allowed since the district championship against Pace on Jan. 27.

After that, St. Thomas Aquinas’ defense played lights out, and the Lady Raiders held on to capture a state-record 16th state championship and their first since 2017.

Niceville will be losing a very impactful senior class that was a huge reason for their success — their best player in Jezlyn Nelson, postseason MVP Michelle Melancon, Reagan Shinn and Taylor Kerle.

  • At the same time, the Lady Eagles return a lot of talent. Abbey Kuritz, Delaney Diehl, Payten Hart, Molly Johnson, Eden Wise, Courtney Gehringer and Shaw are all expected to return.

While losing those seniors is sure to hurt, the Lady Eagles will be back in 2027.

St. Thomas Aquinas’ title is also the school’s second state championship of the 2025-26 school year, following its football team’s Class 5A state title — the program’s seventh straight — after finishing 14-1 and ranked No. 2 in Florida and No. 10 in the country.

PROMOTION

Join the conversation...

Continue reading 👇

Community Comments

“Trusting in Trey Goodwin = INSANITY defined!! Year after year of empty promises... He's "frustrated". He doesn't know how to get it done - so it's about time to replace...”
Respond
Scott Schaeffler commented on WordroW: October 23, 2026
“2:40, 6 attempts”
Respond
“I Love Tiffany, she is such a Joy to be around, so full of life , always ready to help. My kids went to Navarre high school with her and...”
Respond
Scott Schaeffler commented on WordroW: October 22, 2026
“0:20, 3 attempts. Yowza!”
Respond
“I met Tiffany years ago at the Campus Cafe and always knew she would do great things . And she sure has and then same. So proud of her and...”
Respond
“Could it be this area draining into Cinco Bayou is reason water quality there can’t pass standards? People living on and using that waterway should be up in arms to...”
Respond
“DUH….Maybe, just maybe this draining into Cinco Bayou is the reason Cinco’s water quality of late can’t pass the test????? MAYBE….YEP, MOST LIKELY!!”
Respond
“I have lived in Overbrook since 2021 and we have flooded 3 times. Our home is the one that flooded in 2024 from the rainstorm, and we had another flood...”
Respond
“Estimated date cleanup for Lake Lorraine??”
Respond
“If you think it’s bad here go to Gulf Breeze. It’ll take months to clean up there.”
Respond

GET OUR FREE LOCAL NEWSLETTER

Get the weekday email that actually makes reading local news enjoyable again.