Niceville softball avenges last week’s loss with 3-2 win at Crestview

Chloe Bailey struck out eight and Natalie Miller homered as the Lady Eagles held off a late Crestview rally to win their third straight.
Photo courtesy of Travis Espy

Danny Hensley’s squad hasn’t lost at Crestview since 2015, and this year proved no different.

  • Niceville avenged last week’s 3-1 loss with a 3-2 victory Monday night, holding off a furious seventh-inning rally from the Lady Bulldogs to pick up its third straight win.

“I thought we played well. We made a few mistakes at the end, we hit the ball hard all game, we should’ve had eight or nine runs, we left too many baserunners on base,” Hensley said. “But I was proud of the fact that we hung in there, got the win, we’ve beaten three quality teams, and we’re gaining momentum.”

For the first four innings, it was another pitcher’s duel between Niceville’s Chloe Bailey and Crestview’s Cambell Toolan, as both lineups struggled to get going. But someone was due to break through, and it turned out to be Niceville.

Photo courtesy of Travis Espy

In the fifth, after Bailey hit a fly out to start the inning, Carnley Summerlin singled. Sydney Hann, in place of Annabelle Shackelford after Shackelford was injured in the third, reached first on an error by Anna Parker that allowed Summerlin to advance to third. Valerie Malley then put the Lady Eagles on the board with a sacrifice fly that scored Summerlin.

  • Bailey followed that up by striking out three straight batters heading into the sixth.

Krissa Troutman and Quinn Graham both got out to start the inning, but Briana Noles walked, Bailey singled, and Summerlin reached first on an error by Taeia Schriner that scored Noles to make it 2-0 Niceville. Crestview once again went three up, three down in its half of the sixth.

In the seventh, the Lady Eagles had their best inning of the night. After Malley hit a fly out, Natalie Miller launched a home run to put Niceville up 3-0. A Molly Mayfield double gave the Lady Eagles a chance to add on, but outs from Troutman and Kaylee McKissack gave the Lady Bulldogs one more chance.

And quickly, Crestview’s offense, which had been quiet all game, came alive. Toolan flew out to begin the seventh, but Schriner and Parker singled. MacKenzie Toth hit a grounder and was out at first. Summerlin threw to Troutman, who appeared to have Parker out at third for the final out, but after further discussion from the officials, Parker was ruled safe, keeping Crestview’s slim hopes alive.

Tianna Hill then hit a fly ball and Miller was in position to get the final out, but she dropped it, allowing Parker and Schriner to score and cutting the lead to 3-2. That left the fate of the game on the bat of Makenzie Muse.

  • Muse singled, and Hill also appeared to be safe at third, but the officials again discussed the play and ruled that Troutman got the out in time, ending the game and extending Niceville’s winning streak at Crestview to 10 straight.

“That builds character right there. You’re going to have those kinds of situations, and to see our kids answer and respond and make a good play at third to get us out, it speaks volumes about our character,” Hensley said.

Bailey finished with eight strikeouts and allowed five hits.

“Chloe did outstanding. She dominated the game. Her last three outings have just been awesome,” Hensley said.

Niceville (11-6) hosts West Florida Tech on Tuesday.
Crestview (12-6) hosts Todd County Central (Kentucky) on Wednesday.

PROMOTION

Join the conversation...

Continue reading 👇

Community Comments

“Trusting in Trey Goodwin = INSANITY defined!! Year after year of empty promises... He's "frustrated". He doesn't know how to get it done - so it's about time to replace...”
Respond
Scott Schaeffler commented on WordroW: October 23, 2026
“2:40, 6 attempts”
Respond
“I Love Tiffany, she is such a Joy to be around, so full of life , always ready to help. My kids went to Navarre high school with her and...”
Respond
Scott Schaeffler commented on WordroW: October 22, 2026
“0:20, 3 attempts. Yowza!”
Respond
“I met Tiffany years ago at the Campus Cafe and always knew she would do great things . And she sure has and then same. So proud of her and...”
Respond
“Could it be this area draining into Cinco Bayou is reason water quality there can’t pass standards? People living on and using that waterway should be up in arms to...”
Respond
“DUH….Maybe, just maybe this draining into Cinco Bayou is the reason Cinco’s water quality of late can’t pass the test????? MAYBE….YEP, MOST LIKELY!!”
Respond
“I have lived in Overbrook since 2021 and we have flooded 3 times. Our home is the one that flooded in 2024 from the rainstorm, and we had another flood...”
Respond
“Estimated date cleanup for Lake Lorraine??”
Respond
“If you think it’s bad here go to Gulf Breeze. It’ll take months to clean up there.”
Respond

GET OUR FREE LOCAL NEWSLETTER

Get the weekday email that actually makes reading local news enjoyable again.