Search
Close this search box.

Okaloosa Sheriff’s Investigator discusses commitment to solving cold cases, talks 2 specific cases

"There is nothing that cops like better than catching bad guys but we cannot do this without you," says Investigator Micheal Smith.

On Tuesday, Investigator Micheal Smith discussed the Okaloosa County Sheriff’s Office’s commitment to solving cold cases, and insists that the focus on bringing justice never wanes. 

  • In his discussion, Smith addresses two cold cases, both of which are several years old. The first of these cold cases is the murder of Paris Matthews.

Paris Matthews was murdered in 2013 after answering a knock on his door in Fort Walton Beach. Matthews was shot in his doorway, and died quickly thereafter says Smith.

“We gathered hundreds of interviews and thousands of pieces of evidence, but none of this was pointing us in a clear line as to who was responsible for his murder,” states Smith. “The leads just dried up.”

Smith then continues to discuss his second cold case, concerning the murder of Jimmy Lee Dodd in Fort Walton Beach. This one is personal to Dodd as he was the investigator on call the morning Dodd was killed.

“Mr. Dodd was in his home asleep with his girlfriend and something woke him to bring him out of the house. We believe possibly a telephone call or something like that,” explains Smith. “Something caused him to come out early in the morning, before he would normally be waking up, and he was shot dead in his driveway.”

In both of these cold cases, the individuals were deliberately targeted. The reason as to why, has yet to have been uncovered, according to Smith.

“There is nothing that cops like better than catching bad guys but we cannot do this without you,” he says. “We are as passionate as we can be about these cases. We never stop looking. But without direct evidence from witnesses, it’s difficult for us to get across that threshold of probable cause where we can make an arrest in these cases.”

Smith encourages anyone who may have information on either case to please step forward. You can contact the agency at 850-651-7400 or contact Emerald Coast Crime Stoppers at 850-863-TIPS.

PROMOTION

Join the conversation...

Continue reading 👇

Community Comments

“Fire Services took the most impactful hit in my view.”
Respond
“Why are our schools , especially high schools not getting good grades??? It’s very disappointing!!! We need new leadership!”
Respond
Scott Schaeffler commented on WordroW: July 1, 2026
“1:05, 3 attempts. Way lucky on this one!”
Respond
“Seems like Crestview took the hit in regard to cuts. Why are our projects less important OR are our representatives asleep while others get their funds?????”
Respond
Joe P Skelly, M.S., L.M.H.C. commented on Bridgeway Center honors Larry McFarland for 40 years of service
“Larry, hard to believe that 4 decades have passed since you began this journey. As always, your compassion emerges as a beacon for us all.”
Respond
Scott Schaeffler commented on WordroW: June 30, 2026
“0.19, 3 attempts. Got lucky!”
Respond
“Think about how much could’ve been done with the $84m the state spent on a few acres of sand on Holiday Isle. What a boondoggle!”
Respond
Michael Cobb commented on WordroW: June 30, 2026
“1:32”
Respond

GET OUR FREE LOCAL NEWSLETTER

Get the weekday email that actually makes reading local news enjoyable again.